Review of Public Finance Forecasts for 2023 and 2024

2025-01-20T00:00:00+01:00

The economic and public finance forecasts for 2023 and 2024 were drawn up amid much uncertainty with highly volatile energy prices, a very high inflation rate and unprecedented monetary policy tightening.

For 2023, while real growth was closely aligned with the forecast (0.9% vs 1.0%), high levels of inflation provoked more substantial revisions of nominal growth, that was initially projected at 4.6% in autumn 2022 then at 6.8% a year later, and which ultimately stood at 6.3%. For 2024, real growth, that was first forecast at 1.4%, was revised downwards to 1.1%, and the nominal growth forecast was reduced from 4.0% in autumn 2023 to 3.5% a year later as it was affected by the faster-than-expected fall in inflation.

The 2023 general government deficit was –5.5% of GDP (–5.3% excluding the change of base year for the national accounts by Insee, the National Institute of Statistics and Economic Studies), compared to the projection of –4.9% in autumn 2023. The 2024 deficit figure has not yet been finalised: the most recent official forecasts were for –6.1 % of GDP, following a projection of –4.4% in autumn 2023, that was revised to –5.1% in April 2024. These revisions are significant but not unheard of from a historical standpoint.

In 2023, the spontaneous growth in aggregate taxes and social security contributions, i.e. without factoring in discretionary measures, was much lower than that of nominal growth (2.6% vs 6.3% for nominal GDP), in contrast to 2022 which was an exceptional year. Such a contrast was anticipated as early as July 2022 but its scale was much larger than projected. Central government expenditure was lower than forecast unlike local authority expenditure.

In 2024, revenue from aggregate taxes and social security contributions was subject to major reassessments due to unexpected events in 2023 that were heightened by the delayed functioning of corporation tax and income tax. It was also slowed by lower nominal growth in GDP that was less driven by private domestic demand, and which had an impact on VAT revenue. In addition, there was a surprisingly high level of local authority expenditure whilst central government expenditure is expected to be lower than provided for in the 2024 Initial Budget Act due to management measures introduced during 2024.

Update

Following the publication by Insee, the National Institute of Statistics and Economic Studies, of the general government accounts, the 2024 general government deficit was ultimately −5.8%, that is to say 0.3 points of GDP more than the projection used in the 2025 Budget Bill and on the basis of which this edition of TrésorEconomics was produced in January 2025.

Revisions constitute an overall improvement of roughly €9.5bn and essentially concern:

• local authority expenditure (+€6.5bn), which turned out to be lower than expected when the 2025 Budget Bill was being prepared, due to a slowdown in this local expenditure starting in autumn 2024. For instance, local authorities’ investment expenditure rose 7.6% in 2024 compared to the 13.2% increase forecast in the 2025 Budget Bill, which was based on the latest accounting data from summer 2024. Operating expenses rose by 3.5% but this was still significantly less than the 4.6% projected in October 2024.

• central government expenditure (up €3.4bn), was less than forecast in autumn 2024 owing to a budget outturn that was even lower than estimated in the Initial Budget Act.

• the 2023 deficit was also revised to −5.4% of GDP, i.e. up 0.1 points compared to the provisional account published by Insee in May 2024.

Table 1 relating to the revision of the general government balance in 2023 and 2024 between the budget bills for 2024 and 2025 has been updated as follows :

Public Deficit on Target in 2022 Despite the Energy Crisis

2023-07-28T00:00:00+02:00

The 2022 public deficit published by the National Institute of Statistics and Economic Studies (INSEE) on 31 May 2023 stood at 4.7% of GDP. This figure is close to the 5.0% of GDP target set out in the 2022 Budget Bill, as revised on 22 October 2021, and upheld in the two 2022 Supplementary Budget Acts.

However, an imported inflation shock of more than 4 percentage points in 2022 had a strong impact on revenues and expenditure through several channels.

Spontaneous growth of taxes and social security contributions outstripped GDP growth by a wide margin. This major stylised fact was incorporated into the forecasts in the first 2022 Supplementary Budget Bill in July 2022. It stemmed primarily from the components of growth, the strength of wage growth and the large increase in taxable corporate profits in 2021, which has a lagged impact on government revenues.

The inflation shock affected expenditure in two main ways: (i) the indexation of certain expenditure; (ii) the measures implemented since the end of 2021 to protect businesses and households from inflation.

In the fourth quarter of 2021, it was impossible for the Budget Bill to foresee the scale of the energy shock or the measures that would be introduced to support households and businesses. However, the capacity for rapid revisions of forecasts to allow proportionate discretionary tax measures and resolute commitments to the deficit target made it possible to attain a deficit that was close to the original target, despite the shocks affecting revenue and expenditure (see Chart).

Trésor-Info - Publications de la direction générale du Trésor - Elasticity

Review of Public Finance Forecasts for 2023 and 2024

Public Deficit on Target in 2022 Despite the Energy Crisis